The First Amendment to the US Constitution reads:
"Congress shall make no law ... abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press...."*
The US Supreme Court will hold the STEALER of secrets responsible for the theft. The Court will also NOT prevent the publication of secret information unless it can be proven that such information is causing damage. The Court does not consider embarrassment to be damage.
Wikileaks has been really smart and really reasonable about the information that they have acquired. Lawyers around the world should be in awe of the strategy that almost certainly insures the continuing leaking of information. The most important aspects of this strategy has four components.
1. Wikileaks is NOT the only organization that has the information. The information is also in the possession of five respected newspapers in five different countries. They are The New York Times, in the USA; Le Monde, in France; El Pais, in Spain; Der Spiegal, in Germany; and The Guardian, in Great Britain.
2. These newspapers and Wikileaks have spent months redacting (editing) the information so that no person is put in danger. The New York Times had plenty of time to consult with US government agencies about the content of the cables.
3. ALL of these countries have laws protecting freedom of the press and freedom of speech. Each country has slightly different laws.
4. Even if Wikileaks disappears from the face of the earth, the information will still be leaked. Too many people have possession of the information for the information to continue to remain secret.
LET THE COURTS AND THE DIPLOMATS SOLVE THIS PROBLEM. Denial of service attacks are exactly the same as burning books, which most of us deplore.
Freedom of the press and freedom of speech are basic protections essential to democracy. It is not possible to have a working democracy without a full debate on the issues. We need to know things, because the ultimate decisions are up to us, the voters.
OUR COURTS have worked on the problem of protection of necessary secrets since the American Revolution. LET THEM SOLVE THIS.
BTW, people who publish secrets KNOW that they take a risk. I am sorry Assange is in jail, but, as far I know, Britain and Sweden have acceptable systems of justice. Let the British and Swedish courts solve this problem.
* ... means some words were left out because they are not relevant to the current discussion. .... means that the words left out were at the end of the sentence.